Skip to content
By Chris Tomkinson Founder at GoVida - The Employee Wellbeing Platform

Mental health has become one of the biggest conversations in the workplace.

Employers are investing in wellbeing programmes, encouraging people to speak openly about their struggles and providing more resources to support employees.

And yet, mental health remains one of the leading causes of long-term sickness absence.

So, are we making progress? Are more people experiencing mental health problems, or are we simply becoming better at recognising and reporting them? And perhaps most importantly for HR professionals, are we addressing the right problems?

I think there’s another question worth exploring.

Have we become so accustomed to talking about mental health as one broad issue that we’re overlooking the very different challenges sitting beneath it?

Sickness absence: What has changed since COVID?

The latest CIPD research paints a concerning picture.

Its 2025 Health and Wellbeing at Work report found that employees were absent for an average of 9.4 days per year, compared with 7.8 days in 2023 and 5.9 days in its 2019 survey.

That’s an increase of almost 60% against the pre-pandemic survey figure.

However, the Office for National Statistics offers a different perspective. Its 2025 estimates show that 2.0% of working hours were lost through sickness or injury, compared with 1.9% in 2019.

These aren’t contradictory findings. The two organisations use different methodologies and measures, which is an important reminder that we should be careful when interpreting absence statistics.

The CIPD also found that mental ill health was among the three leading causes of long-term absence for 41% of surveyed organisations, ahead of musculoskeletal injuries (31%) and other long-term health conditions (30%).

Meanwhile, the Health and Safety Executive estimated that work-related stress, depression and anxiety accounted for 22.1 million working days lost in Great Britain during 2024/25.

These are significant figures. But before we consider how to reduce mental health-related absence, perhaps we need to understand what we’re actually measuring.

Would we treat every physical health problem in the same way?

Imagine four employees taking time off work.

One has broken their leg. Another is recovering from a heart attack. A third is undergoing cancer treatment, while the fourth is suffering from a recurring migraine.

All four are experiencing physical health problems, but the causes, treatment, recovery times and support they require are completely different.

We wouldn’t expect the same intervention to address every situation.

Yet when we talk about mental health in the workplace, we often group a wide range of conditions and experiences under one heading.

Anxiety, depression, burnout, work-related stress, bereavement and more complex psychiatric conditions can all become part of the same conversation.

Of course, they can overlap, but they aren’t interchangeable.

And if we don’t distinguish between them, how can we expect to provide the most appropriate support?

What actually sits beneath the mental health umbrella?

For HR professionals, understanding some of these distinctions is an important starting point.

Anxiety disorders can involve persistent worry, fear, physical tension and difficulty concentrating. They may affect someone’s confidence, relationships and ability to manage everyday situations. Anxiety disorders also vary considerably, from generalised anxiety disorder to panic disorder and specific phobias.

Depression can affect energy, motivation, sleep, concentration and the ability to experience pleasure. It isn’t simply feeling unhappy or having a difficult week.

Work-related stress is different again. Stress is not itself a psychiatric diagnosis, although prolonged stress can contribute to mental and physical health problems. Excessive workloads, poor relationships, unclear expectations and lack of control can all be contributing factors.

Burnout is another term we hear increasingly often. The World Health Organisation classifies burnout as an occupational phenomenon associated with chronic workplace stress that hasn’t been successfully managed, rather than a medical condition in its own right.

Employees may also experience conditions such as obsessive compulsive disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, bipolar disorder and eating disorders, each requiring its own understanding and appropriate professional support.

Then there are difficult life experiences such as grief, relationship breakdowns and financial pressures, which can have a profound impact on wellbeing without necessarily constituting a mental health disorder.

This distinction matters.

Not every difficult emotion is a mental illness, but that doesn’t mean it should be ignored.

For employers, the objective shouldn’t be to diagnose employees. It should be to recognise that different circumstances require different responses, and to ensure people can access appropriate support.

Are mental health problems actually becoming more common?

There is evidence that some mental health conditions have become more prevalent.

The NHS Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey found that the proportion of adults aged 16–64 in England experiencing common mental health conditions increased from 17.6% in 2007 to 18.9% in 2014 and 22.6% in 2023/24.

That’s a substantial increase, and one that began long before COVID.

However, the picture isn’t consistent across every condition.

The same research found relatively stable prevalence for certain less common psychiatric conditions, while common mental health conditions, particularly among younger adults, showed more significant increases.

So we shouldn’t assume that every aspect of mental health is deteriorating at the same rate or for the same reasons.

And there’s another factor to consider.

As awareness increases and stigma decreases, more people may feel comfortable acknowledging difficulties they would previously have hidden.

That is a positive development.

But could greater awareness also have unintended consequences?

Does talking more about mental health always help?

This is perhaps one of the most interesting questions for employers.

Over recent years, we’ve been encouraged to talk more openly about mental health, recognise symptoms and remove the stigma surrounding psychological difficulties.

There are good reasons for this. Greater awareness can help people recognise genuine conditions, seek treatment and feel less isolated.

However, research from the University of Oxford raises an important question about whether awareness campaigns can sometimes have unintended effects.

In 2023, psychologists Lucy Foulkes and Jack Andrews published a paper proposing what they called the prevalence inflation hypothesis.

Their argument was that mental health awareness efforts could influence reported mental health problems in two different ways.

The first is improved recognition.

People who have previously struggled without understanding why may become better able to identify their symptoms and seek appropriate help.

This is clearly valuable.

The second is overinterpretation.

The researchers suggested that some people might begin interpreting ordinary emotional experiences, such as temporary anxiety, disappointment or stress, as evidence of a mental health disorder.

They also proposed that identifying too strongly with a diagnostic label could, in some circumstances, influence behaviour.

For example, someone who interprets everyday nervousness as evidence of an anxiety disorder might begin avoiding situations they previously felt capable of managing. That avoidance could then reinforce their anxiety.

Importantly, this was a hypothesis, not proof that awareness campaigns are causing mental illness or that employees are exaggerating difficulties.

A subsequent review published in Nature Reviews Psychology in 2026 examined both the benefits and potential unintended consequences of mental health awareness.

The research raises a worthwhile question for HR professionals:

Are we helping employees understand their mental health, or are we sometimes making it harder to distinguish between ordinary life challenges and conditions requiring clinical support?

The answer shouldn’t be to discourage conversations or question employees’ experiences.

Instead, perhaps we need to make those conversations more informed.

Recognising when someone needs professional help is important. So is helping people understand that stress, sadness, uncertainty and occasional setbacks are also part of normal human experience.

Good mental health education should help people make that distinction without minimising either experience.

Is modern life contributing to the problem?

It’s tempting to point towards COVID, social media, smartphones or changing working practices as explanations for rising mental health concerns.

But the reality is more complicated.

Modern life offers many advantages. We have greater access to information, more opportunities to connect with others and, for many employees, more flexibility over how and where we work.

At the same time, digital communication can make it harder to switch off. Social media can encourage comparison. Financial uncertainty can create persistent pressure, and flexible working can sometimes reduce everyday social interaction.

Even changes that benefit one person may have the opposite effect on another.

Working from home might improve someone’s work-life balance while leaving another employee feeling isolated.

The challenge for employers is to understand these differences rather than assume that everyone experiences the modern workplace in the same way.

And importantly, we shouldn’t confuse correlation with causation. The fact that mental health problems have increased during a period of rapid technological and social change doesn’t establish that any single development is responsible.

What can HR professionals do to make a meaningful difference?

If mental health covers such a wide range of experiences, there clearly isn’t one solution.

But there are practical steps employers can take.

1. Understand what’s driving absence in your organisation

Start with the evidence available to you.

Are employees reporting work-related stress? Are long-term absences becoming more common? Are particular departments experiencing greater pressure?

Look for patterns in absence data, staff surveys, exit interviews and aggregated wellbeing feedback, while protecting confidentiality.

Avoid assuming that every absence recorded under mental health has the same underlying cause.

The aim is to understand organisational trends, not to investigate individual medical histories.

2. Address workplace pressures rather than relying on wellbeing initiatives alone

The HSE identifies six important areas of work design associated with stress: demands, control, support, relationships, role and change.

These are areas employers can directly influence.

If excessive workloads, unclear expectations or poor management practices are contributing to stress, introducing a wellbeing app or offering a mindfulness session won’t resolve those underlying issues.

Wellbeing initiatives should complement a healthy working environment, not compensate for an unhealthy one.

3. Help managers have better conversations

Managers don’t need to become mental health professionals.

But they should feel confident recognising when someone may need support, listening without judgement and knowing where to direct them.

They also need to understand that different circumstances require different responses.

Someone struggling with workload pressures may benefit from changes to responsibilities or deadlines.

Someone experiencing depression may need professional treatment, appropriate adjustments and a supportive return-to-work plan.

For employees returning after mental health-related absence, a supportive return-to-work conversation can be particularly valuable. Understanding whether adjustments are needed, agreeing realistic expectations and reviewing any workplace factors that may have contributed to the absence can help make the transition more manageable.

The objective is to understand what will help, rather than make assumptions based on a broad label.

4. Move from awareness to practical support

Mental health awareness campaigns have an important role, but they shouldn’t be the end of the conversation.

Employees need to know what support is available and how to access it.

That might include occupational health, employee assistance programmes, professional mental health services, flexible working arrangements and reasonable adjustments.

Employers should also encourage resilience and healthy coping strategies without suggesting that employees are individually responsible for overcoming harmful working conditions.

The question for HR isn’t simply, “Are we talking about mental health?” It’s, “What happens when someone needs help?” A comprehensive approach to employee wellbeing should combine appropriate support with a healthy working environment and opportunities to build positive habits.

5. Encourage positive habits before problems develop

Much of the workplace mental health conversation focuses on supporting people once they’re already struggling.

But what about helping employees build positive habits as part of everyday life?

Physical activity, social connection, spending time outdoors, mindfulness and creative pursuits can all contribute to wellbeing.

And they don’t have to involve intense exercise or structured wellness programmes.

For one employee, that might mean joining a lunchtime walking group. For another, playing padel, singing in a choir, attending an art class or simply making more time for activities they enjoy.

Inclusive employee wellbeing challenges can help organisations encourage participation, build connections and make positive habits part of everyday working life.

The important thing is to make wellbeing inclusive and accessible, recognising that different activities appeal to different people.

These experiences aren’t treatments for mental health disorders, but they can form part of a positive, preventative approach to wellbeing.

6. Measure what matters

Finally, employers need to understand whether their wellbeing efforts are making a difference.

That means looking beyond the number of awareness sessions delivered or resources made available.

Are employees engaging with initiatives? Do they feel supported? Are managers addressing workplace pressures? Are people developing positive habits and building stronger connections?

Absence trends, anonymous employee feedback and aggregated participation data can all contribute to the picture.

As we explored in our recent article on employee wellbeing tracking, collecting more data doesn’t necessarily mean we’re measuring what matters most.

But no single metric tells the whole story, and increased participation doesn’t automatically prove improved mental health.

Measurement should help employers make better decisions, not simply produce more data.

Moving from mental health awareness to everyday wellbeing

At GoVida, we believe employee wellbeing should be proactive, inclusive and enjoyable.

Our employee wellbeing platform uses engaging challenges, gamification and meaningful rewards to encourage people to participate in activities that support their physical, mental and social wellbeing.

It’s about helping people discover what works for them, whether that’s becoming more active, connecting with colleagues or trying something completely new.

We also believe organisations can encourage positive wellbeing habits without needing to collect sensitive personal health metrics from employees.

Of course, a wellbeing platform isn’t a substitute for professional mental health care, supportive management or a healthy working environment.

But it can help organisations create opportunities for positive behaviour and meaningful participation as part of a wider wellbeing strategy.

Are we asking the right questions?

We’ve made considerable progress in bringing mental health into everyday conversation.

And that’s important.

But perhaps the next stage of workplace wellbeing isn’t simply about talking more.

It’s about understanding more.

Understanding the difference between stress, anxiety, depression and other conditions.

Recognising that not every difficult experience is a mental illness, while ensuring those who need support can access it.

Addressing workplace pressures rather than expecting individuals to manage everything themselves.

And creating environments that help people develop positive habits, build meaningful connections and feel supported.

For HR professionals, the challenge isn’t to solve every mental health problem.

It’s to understand where the organisation can make a difference and take meaningful action.

Because better workplace mental health doesn’t start with having all the answers. It starts with asking better questions.

Related Health & Wellbeing Blogs

The Future of Employee Wellbeing: Are We Measuring What Really Matters?

From 10,000 steps to AI-powered wellbeing, technology can measure more than ever. But should employers know more about employee health? Discover why privacy, inclusion and inspiring positive behaviours may matter more than the data itself.

Read this blog

AI and Employee Wellbeing: Are We Becoming More Productive but Less Human?

AI is transforming workplace productivity, but what does it mean for employee wellbeing? Explore the hidden impact of AI on workplace stress, human connection and work-life balance, and why greater efficiency doesn’t always mean happier, healthier employees.

Read this blog

Employee Wellbeing in 2026: Why It Matters More Than Ever for Building Successful Teams

In 2022, 92% of employees said wellbeing mattered when choosing an employer. Four years on, discover what the latest research reveals about wellbeing, engagement and staff retention.

Read this blog
All wellbeing blogs